The Psychology of Ruin: 8 Traps to Avoid
There is a clear pattern to why investors lose money. It applies just as much to UK investors as it does to Wall Street.
Whether you are managing a SIPP, an ISA, or a general trading account, the pitfalls are identical. While the market feels unpredictable, human behaviour is surprisingly consistent.
Most investors do not fail because they picked the wrong stock; they fail because they succumbed to one of these eight psychological flaws.
1. You Are Playing the Wrong Game
When long‑term savers start taking cues from short‑term traders, they get drawn into bubbles and crashes instead of letting compounding work.
Bubbles form when the crowd shifts from long‑term investing to short‑term gambling. If you are saving for retirement in 20 years, why do you care what a day trader thinks about the market today? As Morgan Housel notes, damage is done when "long-term investors playing one game start taking their cues from those short-term traders."
The Fix: Define your time horizon. If you are not selling for 10 years, today's price is irrelevant.
2. Bailing Out During Volatility
Volatility is not a sign that you are doing something wrong; it is the "price of admission" for good returns.
Many UK investors panic-sell funds after a market drop (selling low) and buy back in only after confidence returns (buying high). This behaviour locks in permanent losses. You cannot have the returns of the stock market without the stomach-churning drops that come with it.
The Fix: View a market drop as a "sale," not a crisis.
3. The Illusion of Skill (Overconfidence)
Legendary investor Ed Thorp argues that genuine stock‑picking skill is rare. Most people should default to broad, low‑cost index funds unless they have a real, provable edge.
You should only "swing at the fat pitches" where you have a clear informational advantage. Unfortunately, many investors chase tips, newsletters, and "story stocks" with zero edge over the market.
The Fix: If you cannot write down why you own a stock in three bullet points, you are gambling, not investing.
4. Ruinous Risks and Leverage
"Overbetting is always bad." Accepting even a small risk of losing everything eventually leads to losing everything (a concept known as the Kelly Criterion).
In the UK, this often manifests as:
- Heavy leverage via CFDs and Spread Betting.
- Concentrated positions in speculative small-cap stocks (AIM market punts).
These are not investments. They are binary bets. If zero is a possible outcome, the bet is too big.
5. Chasing "Momentum"
This involves assuming price streaks will continue without a sound fundamental case. It is "story‑based investing"—seeing patterns where none exist.
We saw this recently with investors piling into tech hype cycles, meme stocks, and crypto. The result is almost always the same: they enter when the hype is high (maximum risk) and exit when the narrative breaks (maximum loss).
The Fix: Ignore the chart. Look at the business.
6. Misunderstanding Risk vs. Return
Managing risk is fundamental, yet most investors get it wrong. They assume that to get higher returns, they must take dangerous risks.
Great investing is not about chasing the highest possible number in a single year. It is about achieving satisfactory returns that you can actually stick with for decades. If you chase the highest return, you usually end up with a portfolio that effectively "blows up" when the market turns.
The Fix: The goal is not to get rich quickly; the goal is to survive long enough for compounding to work.
7. Poor Selling Discipline
Most investors buy with a plan but sell on emotion. There are only three good reasons to sell:
- Rebalancing: To reset your risk levels.
- Thesis Break: The fundamental reason you bought the company is no longer true.
- Need: You actually need the cash for a real-life goal.
You should never sell because of a news headline or short‑term fear. UK investors often do the opposite: selling what went down and buying what went up.
8. Focusing on Returns Instead of Savings Rate
Building wealth has almost everything to do with your savings rate and very little to do with picking the "stock of the year."
You cannot control what the market returns this year (it might be +20% or -20%). You can control how much of your income you save.
The Fix: Invest early, often, and automatically. The "boring" act of saving more money beats the "exciting" act of trying to pick better stocks.
Want more insights like this? Subscribe to the newsletter to get evidence-based investing analysis delivered straight to your inbox.
Disclaimer:
This content is for educational purposes only and does NOT constitute medical or financial advice. I am a healthcare professional, but views are my own and do not represent my employer or regulator. Analysis is based on public data. I am not a regulated advisor. Capital is at risk.